One of our longest discussions started with a short counting puzzle: Six students each shake hands with every other student exactly once. How many handshakes happen?
Several students answered thirty: six people, each shaking five hands. Others noticed that this counts each handshake twice. Ava shaking hands with Ben is the same handshake as Ben shaking hands with Ava. My first hint was small: ‘Choose one student. How many new handshakes does that student create?’
One group acted it out and recorded each handshake. Another drew six dots and connected every pair. A third counted five new handshakes for the first student, four for the second, then three, two, and one. They got 5 + 4 + 3 + 2 + 1 = 15.
A student connected it to a round-robin tournament. Six teams playing each other once also need fifteen games. Then students asked about seven people, twenty people, or any number n. We reached n(n - 1) / 2. The answer mattered less than seeing how several methods could explain the same idea.