Skip to main content
Math Maniacs

Advice for Coaches

How I Learned Not to Give Hints Too Quickly

· by Shayen Maun

During an early meeting, a student paused after a few attempts at a pattern problem. I could see the rule, so I pointed out which numbers to compare. The student quickly found the answer. The problem was solved, but I'd taken away the chance to notice the pattern.

I'd stepped in because the silence made me uncomfortable. The student hadn't actually run out of ideas. Now I start with questions: ‘What have you noticed?’ or ‘What changes from one term to the next?’ If they need more help, I suggest a table, diagram, or smaller example before offering a specific hint.

I also wait longer after asking. A pause can mean someone is thinking. If I fill it immediately, students learn that waiting will get them the next step from me.

A question is almost always a better hint than a sentence. I want to give enough support to keep a student moving without doing the reasoning for them. Figuring something out feels different from following someone else's method.

“A question is almost always a better hint than a sentence.”

Want to bring Math Mania to your school or library?

Schedule a free 15-minute conversation, and we can plan what your first session might look like.